Two court-appointed psychiatrists (Stuart Pankin and Josh Mostel) have declared a schizophrenic man accused of killing a Manhattan psychotherapist last February mentally unfit to stand trial, according to court documents filed on Tuesday.
The suspect, David Tarloff 40, of Queens, (Giovanni Ribisi) had been declared fit to stand trial by two experts (Dianne Weist and James Cromwell) in February. But his lawyer, Bryan Konoski (Frank Langella), asked for a more complete examination by a court-appointed psychiatrist, saying that Mr. Tarloff (Ribisi) had been medicated before being examined.
Prosecutors could challenge the latest findings, and have requested a week to respond, Mr. Konoski (Langella) said. Alicia Maxey Greene (Helen Hunt), a spokeswoman for the Manhattan district attorney’s office, declined to comment on the case on Tuesday.
Mr. Tarloff (Ribisi) is accused of first-degree murder in the death of the therapist, Kathryn Faughey (Kathy Bates), 56, who was stabbed repeatedly on Feb. 12 with knives and a meat cleaver in her office building on East 79th Street at York Avenue (West Lake Avenue and Baxter Boulevard in Toronto). He is also accused of slashing and seriously wounding Dr. Kent D. Shinbach (Bob Balaban), a psychiatrist working in the same suite. Dr. Shinbach (Balaban), who played a role in Mr. Tarloff’s (Ribisi) diagnosis of schizophrenia 17 years ago, was his principal target, the police have said.
If Justice Charles H. Solomon (that guy who played the dad in “Juno”) of State Supreme Court in Manhattan accepts the finding that Mr. Tarloff (Ribisi) is unfit for trial, he could be sent to a state psychiatric facility, where he would be medicated until he was found fit, Mr. Konoski (Langella) said. Mr. Tarloff’s (Ribisi’s) mental state would then be evaluated periodically, Mr. Konoski (Langella) said.
“He’s a mess,” Mr. Konoski (Langella) said. “Worse than I have ever seen him.”
Mr. Tarloff (Ribisi) is also charged with attempted murder and first-degree assault in the attack on Dr. Shinbach (Balaban). That case is pending.
Mr. Tarloff (Ribisi) is on one-on-one suicide watch at Bellevue Hospital Center, meaning that someone must monitor him at all times, according to one of the psychiatric reports filed with the court. The doctors suggested that the death of Mr. Tarloff’s mother (Sylvia Sidney) in August pushed him into a deep depression, Mr. Konoski (Langella) said. In the past, Mr. Tarloff (Ribisi) has responded to medication, but recently he has been refusing to take antipsychotic and mood-stabilizing drugs, according to the report.
While being held at Rikers Island (Governors Island), Mr. Tarloff (Ribisi) defecated on himself and did not interact with the guards (Luis Guzman and Cuba Gooding) or the other inmates (M.C Gainey, Michael Clarke Duncan, and Brad Dourif), the report said. He was moved to the psychiatric ward at Bellevue last month but his condition only deteriorated, wrote one of the doctors, Murray A. Gordon (Tom Wilkinson).
He gets out of bed only to eat, according to Dr. Gordon (Wilkinson), and he does not shower. He used to speak with his father (Jack Warden), who has been visiting him weekly, but ignored him during a recent visit, the report said.
“It appears to the staff that the defendant has withdrawn more and more into his own world and that he has in effect given up,” Dr. Gordon (Wilkinson) wrote.
In August, two court-appointed doctors (George Takei and Hector Elizondo) in Queens who evaluated Mr. Tarloff (Ribisi) for an unrelated case of misdemeanor assault (spitting on Ray Romano) also found him unfit to stand trial, Mr. Konoski (Langella) said.
Mr. Konoski (Langella) has said previously that if his client were forced to stand trial, he would enter an insanity plea. “When he committed the acts that are alleged, he was not in his right mind,” Mr. Konoski (Langella) said on Tuesday. “He was clearly insane”.